Provider Comparison

 
myvidoop

Standards / Protocols:

  • SREG is supported
  • OpenID 2.0 is supported as well

Login:

  • Two-factor authentication by using image categories which the user specified

Security / Phishing:

  • SSL secured transfers
  • EV certificates
  • Customizable notifications (can be used to set alarms when someone tries to login to a user’s account)

Miscellaneous / Future

  • Supports multiple personas, protected from indexing by search engines
  • Password manager for Firefox (compatible with Firefox 3)
  • Partner program for relying parties
  • Microformats enabled public profile page
  • Supported by ID Selector
  • Pavatar support
  • FOAF support in the future

 
openid.ee
(OpenID.ee)

This is an Estonian provider which uses the Estonian identity card (eID) and Mobile-ID SIM cards for identification and authentication.

Standards / Protocols:

  • Partial support of SREG (full name, gender, date of birth).
  • OpenID 2.0 is supported.

Login:

  • eID smart cards
  • WPKI SIM cards (smart cards)

Security / Phishing:

  • All transfers are SSL (no HTTP at all).
  • SeatBelt
  • Authentication methods are phishing resistant. Man-In-The-Middle attacks are possible but phishing is not.
  • Provider Authentication Policy Extension

Miscellaneous / Future

  • No support for multiple personas but personal data filters for different sites which are stored privacy settings for age-gender-fullname.
  • Support for microformats will be added on public profiles.
  • Planned support for One-Time-Password authentication for Java mobile phones.
  • Anonymous identifiers for every interaction between the provider and Relying Party; kind of disposable OpenIDs.

 
signon

Standards / Protocols:

  • Support for SREG
  • OpenID 2.0 is supported

Login:

  • Username/password
  • Information Cards

Security / Phishing:

  • SSL secured transfers
  • Information Cards
  • Provider Authentication Policy Extension
  • SeatBelt
  • Security question and answer
  • Audit log

Miscellaneous / Future

  • No multiple personas
  • Support for SAML
  • Integration with Google Apps
  • No support for microformats and FOAF
  • Future support for other federation protocols like Shibboleth, and WS-Fed

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7